Thursday, August 12, 2010

Papa Gino's

Papa Gino's

Website
Address
10 Harvard St. Brookline MA
Date Ordered
8/1/2010
Where Consumed
Miro's House
Price
$11.99
Order Method
Website
Service Method
Delivery
Delivery Time
31 min
Size (Inches)
15
Price Per Sq Inch
$0.068

Miro Score
Elizabeth Score
Average
Look
3.0
5.0
4.0
Miro's Comments: My usual problem with overly roundness is present, and while there are blackened bits of cheese, they look kinda painted on.
Elizabeth's Comments: It looks crispy, cheesy and with a few air bubbles scattered in.
Smell
5.0
3.5
4.3
Miro's Comments: I know. It's silly, but growing up, Papa Gino's was pizza. Those kind of sense memories are hard to shake.
Elizabeth's Comments: Like cardboard with a hint of basil. I'd probably give it a 3, but there is the pleasant memory of elementary school birthday parties.
Temp
3.5
5.0
4.3
Miro's Comments: Fine temp, nothing special. (I think Elizabeth snuck a bite early).
Elizabeth's Comments: Hot!
Cheese
3.5
4.0
3.8
Miro's Comments: I'd like a little more and a touch more flavor, it's like the franchise pie that it is.
Elizabeth's Comments: Nice covering, but it gets kinda dry and clumpy in your mouth.
Sauce
4.5
5.0
4.8
Miro's Comments: Again, it might be the sense memory talking, but this is the slightly peppery sauce of my youth.
Elizabeth's Comments: Tomatoey, spicy and just the right amount.
Crust
3.5
3.0
3.3
Miro's Comments: The crispiness comes mostly from the cornmeal dusting. But I like the balance and I get a sense of flavor.
Elizabeth's Comments: For thin crust you expect a crisp that isn't there. That said, I don't really like crispiness, but I don't like overly chewy either. This is just a little bit too tough. You need to pull it out of your mouth rather aggressively and the flavor is rather bland.
Overall Taste
4.3
4.0
4.1
Miro's Comments: It's not a gourmet pie, but to me it's pizza.
Elizabeth's Comments: This is a solid reliable pizza. Nothing fancy, nothing special, but so consistent that it hasn't changed since our all you can eat Tuesday swim team dinners.
Value Score
62.64
58.95
60.80
Overall Comments
Miro's Comments: Was, is and will continue to be my favorite choice for a chain-based pizza. When I need to know there's a familiar pizza around, it's Papa Gino's. Apparently that means I can never leave New England, but at least they have them in the city now.
Elizabeth's Comments: We probably should have done this earlier; it gives a good baseline to our readers.
Papa Gino's on Urbanspoon
Papa Gino's
Papa Gino's Pizza

No comments:

Post a Comment